Shelley's Pizza

Shelly's Pizza is a staple of NEPA. The food is absolutely phenomenal. The staff is a crew of extremely polite and hardworking individuals. Even on busy Friday nights, they provide the best service. I decided to order a large pie in the middle of the dinner rush, and was met with a literally steaming hot box in a beyond acceptable amount of time. I have never and will never leave Shelly's unsatisfied, and will always recommend it to anyone who asks me "where should we order pizza?"

Awesome pizza! The crust is thin and crisp, but also chewy. We order our pizza well done with sweet sauce. Sometimes we do add toppings. But it's great plain. They're almost always spot on with their pickup times. I love that they have their pickup window, which is very convenient. The employees are always very nice.

MUST HAVE PIZZA if you're anywhere near by! We drive 9hrs once a year to enjoy the local pizza and Shelly's is always a must, especially their pepperoni pizza!! I've been eating here for over 25 yrs (back when they were in the shopping center) and it's been a favorite this whole time!! Never change!!

Shelly’s Pizza is absolutely delicious and easily one of my favorites in the area! Their sweet sauce is amazing and really sets them apart—it keeps me coming back again and again. I also love how convenient their drive-thru process is. The system with the number boards at the rear of the property makes it so easy to know when your pizza is ready, which is such a nice touch. Great food, great service, and a super smooth pickup experience—highly recommend!

Just had your sweet sauce american cheese with onion well done. I wish you were still open as I tried to call back and tell you how awesome it was. It was worth the 116 calls I made to get through the busy signal. We will get another one tomorrow