Sheeley House Saloon

They were out of prime rib, out of filet, ordered the ribeye medium rare but sort of underwhelmed. Drinks were good. My husband’s shrimp appetizer was awesome, truffle fries were tasty, his fish tacos also good. The ribeye was undercooked and under seasoned. Really neat atmosphere, waitress was pleasant.

Super accommodating and friendly staff. Fun historic haunted house decor. We were with a large group and everyone enjoyed their food. The roasted brussel sprout appetizer was delicious. Highly recommend ordering one of their excellent sauces on the side for dipping fries. Yum!

We stopped in to have a quick lunch and walked in to a BUSY lunch rush! The bars dining tables were full, as well as the side dining area, so we sat at the bar. Joe was the only bartender/server working and I was amazed at how well he handled himself under such a stressful situation! He remained calm and polite! I am extremely impressed. And to top it off, my Hawaiian Long Island and Lunch was great!

I really like their menu! I ordered shrimp dish and there was option to have smaller/half portion. Also seasonal vegetables as sides is a great plus because as Polish I suffer to have enough vegetables in a restaurants. To sum up - great spot, friendly service, lovely outdoor area.

We had dinner here on our last night visiting family. The service was great, super attentive and accommodating. The food was fantastic. I had the walleye special which was perfectly crispy fried fish and had a side of mashed potatoes and sautéed veggies. It was not only delicious but also beautiful to look at. The restaurant itself is fun and historic and felt like an experience, you can tell the building has a story to tell. Some people say the place is haunted and even the back of the menu tells ghost stories which l really enjoyed reading. Would love to come back next time we go visit!