Señor Taco Mexican Grill & Bar

Up until today was a fluent customer. Bi weekly if not weekly some months. Never once had an issue or complaint. Ordered two quesadillas today for 30$ and not only did I wait an extra 25 minutes for them to make these, it came with maybe 1 or 2 little pcs of chicken in each slice. Since I eat these often I knew this was not how they normally are. I Called up explained I already ate them not looking to have them remade or credited, just wanted to let them know about the quality issue incase the cook is as new or maybe they didn’t realize. Allison was nice explained she would credit my account for next time I came in which was not an expected, but deff appreciated. Fast forward an hour later Allison had to call back and tell me the manager watched the cameras and made the decision not to

If you’re looking for a spot that never misses, Señor Taco in Smithtown is it. We’re locals & also own a business on Smithtown Blvd… we come in often for an after-work bite, and I honestly don’t think we’ve ever had a bad experience here. It’s one of those places you can count on every single time. We originally became super loyal to Emily..she treated us like family. Now Allison and Ryan take care of us, and they’ve completely blown us away with their service. Ryan started out just cleaning our tables, and watching him grow into an incredible waiter has been awesome. You can tell he really cares. Allison is absolutely hysterical, and together they make us feel genuinely welcomed every time we walk in…not like customers, but like regulars who matter. Great food, consistent quality, and

Went in person to order the female who took my order was very bland and had no personality. I don’t know if she knows she’s in the service industry. A little smile would’ve been nice. I’m not that picky but a nice attitude or smile goes a long way. She looked like someone killed her puppy. Ordered the ground beef burrito and a large quesadilla. Quesadilla was great burrito barely had any ground beef. I ordered steak burrito previously and had the same issue with the quantity of steak. I’ve ordered burritos etc from places that are cheaper in price but give a decent amount of meat.

Disappointing Decline Over the Years I’ve been a customer of Senior Taco since they opened years ago, but unfortunately, the experience has gone dramatically downhill. What was once a reliable and reasonably priced spot has become increasingly frustrating. Prices continue to climb, yet the portions shrink noticeably. More concerning is the growing inconsistency in orders. It’s now routine to find missing items or incorrect substitutions. Paying $3 extra for guacamole on a burrito only to get home and realize there was none. Paying $15 for a large quesadilla and receiving a small. A side of pico, priced at $10, came in an 8oz container that was just half full. Same with their guacamole, $13 - 8oz container of guac has never been more than 3/4 full and was visibly brown the last time I pu

My cousin took me to Señor Taco recently and absolutely loved the food here! The indoors is a bit small but fortunately they also have outdoor seating. There is also a bar inside the restaurant which is very very cozy. The bartender seemed to be very friendly as well. I ordered three tacos "el dorado style" which practically means it comes with a soft AND hard shell. The tacos themselves were delicious. Highly recommend. Finally don't cheat yourself by not getting their margaritas. I got the cucumber margarita with a salt rim and it was DIVINE. Definitely come by Señor Taco if you're in the area. 🌮