Sexton's Pizza

Completely frustrating experience. We waited 2 hours for our order, only to get home and find the pizza crust was charred/burnt. To make matters worse, there is no way to contact the restaurant. They have no listed phone number, and the number provided on Toast is disconnected or fake. It’s clear customer service isn’t a priority here. Save your money and go somewhere that actually wants to talk to their customers.

Ordered A pizza with pepp and sausage on the entire pie and basil, peppers, onions and mushrooms on one half. We did not have any sausage and the veggies were only on two slices…not half. Order 107 at 5:30 on 2/20. Do better.

I have been looking for my perfect Pizza for 1 year and 2 weeks, since I moved to Ohio. I finally found it! Sexton’s Lewis Ctr. Growing up I lived in the mid-Atlantic, East Coast area, so between PHL and NY, I had tasted some of the best. After retiring I moved to Wyoming, NO Pizza there! I was thrilled when I found Sexton’s. The crust perfect thickness, the pizza sauce was very fresh, and FILLED with flavor. And I cook gourmet. 😃 Only 1 problem…when you are full, you can’t stop eating, it’s that delicious! Keep up the great work y’all. Sincerely, with Pizza Love, Lisa “The Pizza”

Has a sports bar looking feel. A few signature drinks. Next time I will try the watermelon mint mule. Pizza was good but not crispy on the bottom and sauce didn't have enough salt in it. Pizza also could benefit from a drizzle of olive oil. I will definitely be returning.

we ordered take out for two NY style pizza's. by the time we got home the pizza crust was still crunchy and delicious! the toppings are high quality and the sauce is good. no pics this time because we ate it too fast. definitely a new favorite local spot