Secret Pizza

Have heard great things about Secret Pizza as it is our neighbors go to spot for NY style pies. Decided to head here on a Saturday evening as we were coming back from LAX. I’ve forgotten how bad traffic was on the 101 and took us about an hour from Hollywood. Parking here was also pretty bad as we didn’t realize how tight Browne Ave was. Found a spot up front although part of my car was in the red zone. Opted to order 2 slices of pepperoni and garlic knots to eat there while we waited for a sausage/pepperoni and double mushroom pie to take home. Slices of pepperoni were good and thought the garlic knots were just ok. I prefer the garlic rolls at Tarantino’s in Pasadena more as they are really garlicky and buttery. Both pies travelled well and we ended up eating another slice of each at h

Really enjoyable pizza spot. It has a very cozy and genuine atmosphere. The staff is always super friendly and kind. The chocolate chip cookie is unreal. If you plan on getting a whole pie, I’d recommend ordering online since it *can take an hour to cook up (*disclaimer* I’ve only ordered during peak business hours so that’s why it’s been up to an hour). I will most definitely be coming back.

It’s very rare for me to say “this is exactly how I wanted my pizza” when I visit new locations. This place was definitely the one. Good thin and crispy crust. The sauce and cheese is just right, not too much or too little. Will be going back.

The pizza is amazing, truly. We’ve tried many pizzas all over LA, and I even make my own. Not only is every flavor so good, but it passes our test of, is it good room temp, cold, and reheated? YES, it’s all good. The plain cheese is actually our favorite, and that’s a feat in itself. And the owner is an absolute sweetheart, he’s so kind and he cares so much about the service and quality of his restaurant. He often comes out to check in on patrons. Can’t recommend this place enough 💯

Great service- casual, friendly staff. Tried margherita, vodka and pepperoni pizza. They all tasted fresh, light and crisp. The vodka in particular stood out for me in flavor and is the one I'd go back for. They also have canned wine and beer available.