Seafood Island Bar & Grille

We went for the gator tail and ended up ordering the fried pickles as well. Excellent gator tail. Flounder plate was healthy and good. Stuffed shrimp were fantastic.

This. This is the best deal in town. The seafood was amazing I got Mahi Mahi, shrimp poppers and stuffed crab and let me just tell you how amazing it was, but what struck me most was the quality of food for the price! What you see on my plate all only cost $25 and that’s including the tip!! Love that they give out two sides for free with hush puppies. Would recommend.

We love Seafood Island! We’ve been twice so far and will definitely be back many more times. We’re new to the area (living in St. Nicholas) and have started venturing into San Marco more, and this spot has quickly become a favorite. The restaurant is very clean inside, the service has been consistently great, and the food is delicious. What we really appreciate is that they offer so many options beyond just fried seafood, so there’s something for everyone. Highly recommend! First time we both got platters. I got a pick two with salmon and garlic Parmesan wings with sweet potatoes fries and fried green tomatoes. All gr8! My husband got the similar item with Thai chili wings and salmon Second time my husband ordered the snow crab leg dinner I got a pick three with gator tail, fried shrimp

We enjoyed the Sunday Special of 20 Grilled Shrimp. The shrimp were excellent and the gumbo was delicious. I would definitely eat here again and would highly recommend. The staff was very good and very helpful. Thanks

I ordered the three-piece meal grouper scallops And oysters the scallops on my plate and my wife's were overcooked so was the grouper we both had them blackened. The scallops are not real scallops they are shark plugs. If you know Seafood then you will know scallops are not all the same size and same thickness. As far as the grouper it was overcooked they did re-cook our meal and it was better but it was not great and I'm not even sure if it was real grouper. We also had gator bites which were good, the red beans and rice was about the only thing that tasted good out of the whole meal. The fried tomatoes were decent it needed more flavor. They had a special on shrimp 30-piece shrimp for 12.99 with two sides the shrimp were overcooked and it seems like those were frozen pre battered shrimp