Scotto's Pizza

Sometimes Scotto's Pizza is good, sometimes it's bad - this time, it was only okay. I ordered a pepperoni slice and a sausage slice, but neither quite lived up to my expectations. The crust was a bit too doughy for my liking, and the toppings didn't have as much flavor as I was hoping for. However, I will say that the slices were generously sized and the price was reasonable. The atmosphere of the restaurant was pleasant, with plenty of seating and a friendly staff. While my experience was only okay, I would be willing to give Scotto's another try to see if I can find a menu item that I truly enjoy. Overall, Scotto's Pizza in East Windsor is a decent option if you're in the area and looking for a quick bite to eat. However, keep in mind that sometimes the quality can be hit or miss.

We stopped by this place on our way to NY traveling from KY, what a wonderful surprise. Authentic Italian fare, every bite so delicious. The menu had so much to offer it was difficult to choose between entrees. So my family all tried something different so we could share. The service was top notch, kind and very prompt. We would highly recommend this place. Unfortunately there are not any signs off the turnpike highlighting this place, I wonder how many folks miss out on eating here! We would definitely come back. Bonus: it was a beautiful day so we sat on the patio, clean and breezy, enjoyed every minute! 💚

such tasty food, they’ve got the kind of fries people dream about. so perfectly crispy, just your ideal pizzeria fries. i also got the chicken franchese dip sandwich and it was unreal. it even tasted just as good reheated the next day. i highly reccomend stopping by and i will be coming back in the future

Excellent food and decent beer selection. The staff is friendly. Even the dudes in the kitchen are friendly. The bathrooms could use some love.

I ordered a pizza delivered. It was a Brooklyn pie. I kid you not, it was one of the best pizzas I've ever had. The plum tomato sauce was fantastic and the cheese was wonderful. I wouldn't change a thing. This is a true jewel of a pie. Please never change it. Go there, order it and enjoy.