Sayville Bait & Tackle

New owners, BEWARE. Will not be returning after coming here for 3+ years. Used to love their house made potato chips but was told they don’t offer them anymore even though they’re on the menu. 3/4 of the entrees were wrong. The wrap that says comes with fries on the paper menu and online, in fact, did not come with fries. Instead of just bringing us fries, they comped our drinks. Come to get the bill and the chicken caesar wrap with NO FRIES was $24 where on the menu it says $20. Mind you, the steak sandwich was $23. How a lettuce wrap with no side costs more than a literal steak sandwich is beyond me. All said, our waiter was great, he did everything he could for us. There was not even a manager to talk to, or maybe they were hiding in the back because their new owners suck. Sad

A Crispy Chicken sandwich with hot sauce on the side is the way to go. It's good to control how much hot sauce goes on your sandwich. Wish they had more non-alcoholic beer selections. We went during trivia night so it was a little loud but it wasn't that bad.

I've been there twice because I was meeting people who like the place. I've not been impressed either time. Sayville has a number of places that are comparatively priced with better atmosphere and very likeable wait staff and bartenders.

We paid our 50 dollar bill with a credit card and left a generous tip on the table not realizing our waiter already took a tip out with the bill. I’m sorry I never heard of a waiter taking his own tip. I always thought it had to be a party of 8 it or more. I will not be back . Waiter received a 21 dollar tip for a 50 dollar meal.

Excellent bar super friendly staff..great atmosphere. Def. Stop by if you're in town!!