Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria

Amazing service at Salvatore's! They stayed 30 minutes past closing to get an order ready for my son's birthday. Brendan was super friendly and went above and beyond. Truly appreciate the extra effort. Highly recommend 😊

Ordered a sheet and 2 dozen wings for a party last weekend. Every thing went very smooth, wings were perfectly crisp and saucey. Pizza was warm and had proper amount of toppings and tasted very good. Have earned repeated visits from our family.

Pizza was not great. Thi is an edited review after I just spoke to the shop. Paid for double mac salad and got the corporate answer that they weighed the pizza and gave me that. Sorry, no you didn't. If this is double, then I'm done. I don't care what you charge, but give me what I pay for

The fish dinner here did not disappoint. I highly recommend anyone to try it for yourself. Don't forget to get a pizza or anything else on the menu, the food is always good. The other thing I want to mention is how nice the employees are and how they keep the store so clean, I was impressed. The dining area is comfortable with a TV and nice size booths.

Glad there is pizza in Macedon. Stopped by for lunch on a Tuesday. There was a backlog of orders, but the people behind the counter got it done swiftly. Reasonable wait time. In and out in under 20 minutes. I ended up with a slice, wings, and a brew. Took it to a local park for better scenery. Macedon is great, but terrible infrastructure in the canal town by Lock 30. Salvatore's is located in a very desolate and empty part of town. Location not great, but the inside is clean and well maintained.