Sal's Pizza Cedarburg

The spices of pizza we had were excellent. The stuffed crust pepperoni and sausage and the BBQ Chicken slices were so good. Can't forget the garlic knots... phenomenal. Not sure when the ownership changed but it is back to what I remember when the original Sal owed it!!!

Amazing place, everyone was so kind! I was reading a sign, and the worker asked me if I needed anything, or if I would like some Parmesan or pepper. The atmosphere was amazing, I really loved that everything was so cozy and local. The pizza was amazing, would recommend the stuffed pizza and the cheese pizza. All the negative reviews were false. Overall, it had a great atmosphere with kind workers and great food!!!! Stop by here if you are in the area!!

My friend and I visited Sal's in Cedarburg. A first for both of us. The pizza was freshly made and wayyyy beyond our expectation!! Don't even get me started on the garlic knots! Yummyness all around. Well done! Kid making the pizzas was super friendly as well. But to my surprise...I just learned there's a Sal's in Portage (way closer to home). Excited to try there too. My friend and I can't stop talking about how good the pizza was. Sal's made our day!!

Sal’s Pizza is the best NY-style pizza in town and the only pizzeria open on Sundays! Beyond the delicious pizza, the customer service was outstanding. They quickly corrected a miscommunication with our order and handled it with such care and kindness.

We ordered supreme slices, which came with garlic knots. The knots were good, but the pizza was not. The crust is just kind of ridiculous, which as we all know makes or breaks a pizza. Clearly pre-made and spongey. Toppings, including cheese, were sparse. Flavor was definitely lacking. Was a little shocked by the high price too! Their pizza used to be really good. We won't be going back.