Rustic Pizza & Pasteria

We had such a great experience here! The service was excellent, friendly, attentive, and quick to make things right when needed. We ordered the upside-down personal pan pizza with pepperoni, and it was absolutely delicious, crispy, cheesy, and full of flavor. The linguine with meatballs and marinara was also amazing, topped with creamy ricotta and fresh basil. For drinks, I had the red sangria, which was refreshing and perfectly balanced. My friend had a strawberry Limoncello spritz that she really enjoyed. We also tried a pistachio latte (so good!) and a Nutella cappuccino, both worth ordering again. The only thing that missed the mark was the cannolis; they were supposed to be pistachio and cookie butter but didn’t really taste like either. However, our server was fantastic and immedi

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Rustic Pizza on Richmond Rd is a must-try. Came here on a recommendation from Joe the bartender at Stone House, and it absolutely lived up to the hype. Another outstanding spot from the Bread & Butter Hospitality group. The food was excellent across the board—so good I was slow taking photos because I was too busy eating. Full bar, great wine selection, and very fair pricing. Easily one of the best bang-for-your-buck restaurants on Staten Island. I’ll definitely be back soon.

We started with the cesear salad and the not knots. The salad wasnt very good wouldnt get that again. The garlic knots were very good though. We also got a personal margarrita pie to share which was pretty good. It was on focaccia which was interesting and fluffy. Then we got meatball and chicken parm. The meatballs werent our thing wouldnt get those again. The parm was good but not amazing

Our host Violet was so sweet and professional! Our waitress Alexis was extremely sweet, attentive and very familiar with the menu items. The food was absolutely delicious. We also has the regular pie and some chicken tenders for the kidos. We will be back!

Best Pizza on the island. We enjoyed every app we tried. Service is good, but the recent waitress was not trained well. Didn't know about 50% off game days, even after I told her about the deal. She didn't know the family style menu item for my friend's visit who I recommended this place to. They received 4x of each family meal item and charged 4x.