Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard

Worst experience with Rita’s. Looks like the chocolate custard was mixed with a lot of water, so the ingredients were not able to blend properly. Also the portions were way smaller than other branches. First and last time buying at this location

Rita's of Sayerville gave me an awesome experience! The product was exceptionally delicious and the treat team was extremely respectful and helpful! The new owners are doing a GREAT job and I can definitely see a positive change from before. The store is clean, the product tastes great and the service is amazing! I can't wait to come back and enjoy more of this delicious Rita's!

I've eaten a lot of frozen treats in my day. A lot. Tortoni in restaurants, ice cream sammiches from the corner store, tubs of Häagen-Dazs from the supermarket, Brooklyn street corner treats like pirágua and coquito, italian ices at pizzerias, etc. Like grandpa always said: if it's cold and sweet, I'm ready to eat...okay, I'm lying, he never said that. I just made it up... but it's a credo to live by. Anyway, love ice cream but frozen custard (made with eggs) is better. Love Italian ice but homemade ice with stuff in it is better. Rita's has THE BEST Italian Ice and THE SECOND BEST frozen custard (after that banana custard place in Coney Island). Enjoy both by getting a "Gelati" as they call it. This here is a "5 Layer Gelati" that, I guess is only here this summer. I got Black cherry ice

I'm giving this Rita's Italian Ice location 5 stars because it's the best one. They carry the most selection of custard flavors out of all the locations I've been too. Rita's custard is absolutely delicious! My favorite flavors are cheesecake and cake batter. Today I had a gelati with marshmallow peanut butter cream ice and cake batter custard. It was SO GOOD! I highly recommend Rita's Italian Ice in Parlin!

I’m just writing this bc we decided not to go to Rita’s again. First time this year and my last . Too expensive and very disappointed bc it was small also. Barely put any ice cream. We felt like we wasted our money and should have just gotten a McFlurry at McDonald’s bc honestly it tastes the same. The workers seem friendly that’s why it’s 2 star.