Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard

I’ve always enjoyed coming to Rita’s, but lately the experience hasn’t been the same. The girl at the front can come off a bit unfriendly,to put it mildly, and I’ve noticed others feel the same way. I’m not trying to be negative — just hoping for a warmer, more welcoming vibe like it used to be.

Had a great experience visiting Rita’s of Monsey today. Everything was cholov Yisroel which was a great plus! Shua was a great employee and helped explain the menu very well. Will be back!!

SUGAR FREE dragon fruit is so good!!😋🍧

I was reluctant to go there due to warnings about crowds and poor Covid safety compliance. I finally tried on a school day mid-afternoon. There were no other customers, but there is a prominent sign requiring masks and the workers wore them. The ices taste great and service is friendly. I will go again as long as they continue to respect my safety. I am also thankful that they carry chol over stam products as some of us prefer to have a choice.

Rita’s on the 59 is delicious and the inside is very clean. The staff was very friendly and works quickly. They do have the option for cholov yisroel ice cream in addition to the standard frozen custard. Id highly recommend giving this place a try. I’ll definitely be coming back