Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard

This is the best treat ever. I love it so much and it is so good. Everyone should go here and get blue raspberry or pink lemonade. I wish blue raspberries and pink lemons were real fruits.

I am not sure why I waited for 2 years to try Rita’s!! I stopped by today on a rather warm day to just try a different type of ice cream. The frozen custard swirl is deliciously thick, creamy and sinfully delicious. The strawberry custard with cookie dough and apple pie toppings was such a drool worthy combination. We loved the walk through order concept (ordering from outside) since we had our dog and it worked out so well since the customer service was so quick despite the long lines. Got our orders in less than 2 minutes. They have nice pup custard cups which were so cutely made. Costed a $1.25 but worth the quantity. The place is super busy on a hot day but the lines quickly move by!

Tried their new Pumpkin Pie Concrete Custard and it was DELICIOUS!!! Limited time and I would definitely recommend it!

Best ice cream in Carmel. Hannah makes the best concretes ever and never does us wrong!!!

I tried it for the first time last week and IT WAS AMAZING! The owners are AWESOME and were so helpful and warm. They let us try ANY of the flavors and were just so sweet. We went back the next day and will ONLY go to this Rita’s because the owners were amazing. I personally think this one is the one to go to in Indy. This has become an addiction to us. We LOVE IT!