Renzo's

Very disappointing even with the correction. Order a cheese steak hero a few weeks back ordered around closing time. Requested extra cheese and no onions. Very specific confirmed no onions 3 times. Of course picked up the order got home filled with onions. Felt it was innocent mistake closing time everyone was in a rush. Called the next day to explain what happened they excepted responsibility took my information and said I would “be in the book” to just call when I was ready. Sadly I guess there is no book because when I called tonight and said I was in the book they had no idea what I was talking about blamed it on someone that conveniently stopped working there and would be the only person that new about me or the book. Just sad that even after they mess up the order they mess up fixing

Delicious food and friendly staff! one of the best chicken parm slices i ever had , all their food is excellent highly recommend! i come at least 2 times a week.

New owners and not the same. Grandma pie used to be a full box (16 slices) and is now half that but same cost. Flavor wasn’t bad but missing the finishing garlic and crust was too thick and doughy. Also order two pepperoni pinwheels and ended up with two strombolis, not sure how that happened. It’s not Renzo’s so should change the name

So I heard Renzo’s had a new owner so of course I had to stop in and check it out!I heard the old owner retired. I went in and ordered a slice and it was DELICIOUS as always!I met the owner he is a wonderful as well. He kept the same staff and added a few new faces! Welcome to the town!!!

The quality of this pizzeria completely depends on who's cooking that night. Nothing is consistent and you never know what you're going to get when you order.