Red Tomato Urban Pizzeria

We have ordered from here for many years. Always reliable. Tonight we anticipated a long wait (Halloween) so we ordered early. We were told it would be an hour wait, which is totally reasonable for Halloween. After an hour and a half we called, and they told us it would be 30 more minutes as they had gotten "busy." After another 30 minutes, we called and they told us its going to take longer. I explained that one hour was turning into over 2 hours, and the girl repeated that "its going to be longer" and hung up on me. To be clear, long waits happen, as do delays. However, it is extremely unacceptable to hang up on a customer who is simply trying to find out where a long overdue order is. Next year be a little bit more aware of your order capabilities, but more importantly dont han

Honest review. Our company just moved in to the area and we are searching for our "pizza joint". The pizza was good..but it bacame obvious to me that the man running the show is 100 percent commited to his customers by making it a seemless experience. Reciept..condiments..and suggestions. Good job sir.

First time ordering here. Ordered a pizza on the go. Half plain, half sausage. The taste was good. The pizza crust was very thin , it almost wasn't the same consistency with every slice. Also it was runny to the point if you were to pick it up everything woulda flopped right off . Definitely will not go back. This was a Friday evening so maybe rushing through orders, etc. But still shouldn't have had that experience.

The food here never disappoints! Hands down the best tasting and most consistent Italian restaurant in the Marlboro/Colts Neck area.

My go to pizza spot lately. The pizza is super tasty and the crust is always nice and soft. The staff is also always very friendly and welcoming. I like that they have different varieties, i think it’s also good pricing