Red Label Coffee Co.

Stopped into Red Label Coffee Co. in Merrick and was blown away. Tiffany served us both days — she was incredible! Super friendly, genuine, and we had such a wholesome chat with her. She gave us great recommendations and made the whole experience feel personal and welcoming. The menu is unreal — so many specialty lattes and unique options to choose from. We tried the Oreo, Toasted Marshmallow, and Captain Crunch iced coffees, and every single one was phenomenal (and at great prices too). It was honestly so good that we came back the very next day. If you’re anywhere near Merrick, this place is a must-visit. Amazing coffee, amazing staff, and an all-around cozy, positive vibe. Tiffany deserves a shout-out for making our mornings! ☕️✨

First time here and I tried the Almond Biscotti hot coffee. DELICIOUS! Tiffany was very friendly and personable. I highly recommend this coffee shop. I'll be back!

After two visits I’ve found that beneath the razzle-dazzle of dozens of different iced coffee flavors, the coffee itself—the humble, foundational cup of joe—is a disappointment. I tried the banana chip muffin iced coffee, which tasted too artificial. If someone tells you these flavors are natural, look them in the eye and politely decline to be gaslit. Even the regular brew offered no redemption—just scorched notes, like a pot left too long on a hot plate. Good coffee doesn’t need fireworks. It needs care. Clarity. Roast profiles that speak rather than shout. Until that shows up here, I’ll keep looking elsewhere for my morning faith. Personal Rating: 4.0

*Edit: Have patience!! This is not Starbucks cranking out 100 drinks every 10 minutes, if it’s busy there will be a wait. The coffee is good, it’s worth it! This place is brand new, so bad reviews in the first week or so are unnecessary! Give the place a chance to get in the groove people!!! I got the butter butter iced coffee and the cookie butter latte today. Both tasted incredible, smelled amazing, and will definitely have me coming back to try some more. The staff was very friendly and the place was super clean!

10/10 recommend. I got a small Iced Coffee in the flavor Fudgesicle- CARAMEL CHOCOLATE ALMOND + FUDGE.