Quincy's Steak and Comfort Food

Stopped by here on a weekend getaway to see the leaves change. Know that they have a daily special and that’s all in case you’re expecting a larger menu. We decided to order the Mac and cheese side to split before our meal and it was by far the absolute worst we have had in our lives. No flavor, just a glob of goo. We left it and hardly touched it because trust me- it’s not worth the calories. The prime rib itself was OK and the baked potato was actually great. However, the worker in blue leggings was our server and was cussing like a sailor throughout the restaurant our whole time there. At one point we could hear her on the other side of the restaurant complaining about her coworkers. Because her attitude the whole time, the atmosphere wasn’t good.

We have eaten at many of the other Quincy's. We were staying in Salida on our way to Ouray. Buena Vista was the closest Quincy's steak. I can honestly say, this was the best filet mignon! It was the most tender and flavorful filet that I have had. Heather, our waitresses was excellent! We never lacked and she was an excellent guide on near by city attractions.

Alyssa was our server and was outstanding. Very attentive and fun to chat with. The food was so so so good. I got the Salisbury steak special which was outstanding. The other 3 in our party got the prime rib, and cleaned their plates! We can’t wait to come back. Highly highly recommend!

After reading the review of the screaming in the kitchen a few weeks prior, we were rather hesitant to enter, but couldn't find another restaurant for our evening meal that was more than sandwiches or burgers. We were told upon entry only Prime Rib was being served on this Friday night, or the few specials on the board. We didn't really want the prime rib, but one of the specials looked good, so we were seated. Don't you know, the special, we were interested in was not available after all. So we went with the prime rib and ordered it medium well. It looked pretty pink, but it was cooked enough to be edible. The baked potato was great. The mac and cheese was pretty good. The margarita was way too sweet with triple sec, I guess. We barely drank that. The waitress was very attentive at first

Ok...I had previously had a review 6 months ago which was a 3 star and not good...we went last night and they absolutely redeemed themselves!!! Alyssa was our waitress she was amazing 👏!!! She frequently checked on us and was super friendly!!! Our food was fantastic!! We like our prime rib rare and it came out perfect!!!I will definitely return on Alyssa's shift she made our visit well worth our return!!!!