Pudgie's Pizza, Pasta & Subs - Sayre

Placed a pickup order for a small pizza and garlic sticks. had to wait an extra 10 minutes, and I was given a personal pizza with mozzarella sticks. not what I ordered. when I asked about the garlic sticks I was told I'd have to wait 5 more minutes. waited 15 more minutes before asking about them again, and was told to again wait 3-4 more minutes. I never used to have a problem at this location, but they screwed up my entire order this time and was never even given a "sorry".

Who else would be 'fried' for paying $20 for a piece of burnt fish?! These photos are what I'm going to *try* to eat, later. The worst of it had already gone into the garbage. The shift manager, Trevor, didn't say a WORD, not anything even approaching an apology when he put this excuse of a fish-fry in front of me. Utterly *insulting!* Before this, the manager (Trevor again) was going to charge my sister $2.50 for water. I thought it must surely have been a mistake! I explained she was getting water, not a fountain drink; to which he replied, "Yes, I know. But my boss told me I have to start charging for cups." Unbe-flippin-lievable!! So! If you're "Okay" w/ shelling out $20 precious dollars, to be insulted w/ burnt, dried-out fish and be charged $2.50 for a STINKIN' CUP, Pudgies of Say

I was in the Valley and walked in. Brand new customer. I am now saying that this is the best pizza anywhere. I bought one slice. Perfect. It is impossible to have a better slice than what I bought. Great restaurant. Will try the other Pudgie locations also. Update: went back. Still excellent.

The dough was good , however there was very little cheese almost like not having any and same goes for the sauce. The service was very friendly and restaurant was peaceful and relaxing.

Stromboli was under cooked inside and almost burnt outside, asked for a different slice than was given as well. Asked for marinara sauce and the helper walked off. Ended up with poor service and feeling sick.