Procopio's Pizza

We usually enjoy the Sicilian pizza from here, but tonight's order (chicken bacon ranch Sicilian) was extremely disappointing. The pizza was much smaller than usual- 12 pieces instead of 16, and those pieces were smaller in size as well. There's only one size to order for Sicilian so that wasn't the issue. Also, the crust was thin and toppings so light especially around the edges that it was mostly crust and ranch.

We usually order the same things. This time it was awful. Nothing looked right. The fries were small and didn’t look or taste good. Minimal sauces on what we ordered and the bruschetta was just tomatoes. I called and he said it was the same but it is not. Very disappointing Update: Received multiple rude text messages an hour after calling to get a replacement bruschetta. The customer service as you can see below is less than kind. I would not recommend this company. Based on treatment alone of customers. We’ve been placing the same basic order for years. We know what it normally looks like. Mistakes happen but treating customers in this way is rude. And it’s the wife you are talking to clearly my name is above.

Food was FANTASTIC ! We ordered 2 personal pizzas , cheesy bread, garlic knots , fries , chx Alfredo, garlic bread ! All the food came out hot and as ordered and was absolutely delicious! They even gabe us an order of cannolis for Valentines day ! Service was great , very friendly , will definitely be back !!!!

First time ordering and food arrived SUPER cold. I called and ask them to make it right and he said verbatim "we dont really offer delivery, I asked my friend to bring the pizza to you"... It literally has a flyer in the pictures of the Google business that says "we deliver" and the receipt says "for delivery"... we won't order from here again. Fries were super small and the boneless wings were a joke. 20-30 tiny pieces of scap fried pieces with no chicken inside of them.

Ordered a medium pizza and an order of stuffed shells, thru door dash. Almost 54.00 dollars???? Thats insane!!!!!!! Just went there today 1/31/26 called and ordered a pizza to go. Got there and they said I didn't call there, I must have called the one in Indiana. I said I know where I called as I have them on speed dial, was going there for over 20 years. I said that I would bring my phone in, and if it shows I did call, the pizza is free, if not I would pay double. He declined. I got the phone, showed him, the bozo had to look at their phone to check the number there. Needless to say, I won't be going there anymore, really shitty service and argumentative. Giovanni's now has my business!!!