Poseidon's Pizza

I placed an order for 2 large pizzas and an order of garlic knots. I had placed the order for a 5:30 pickup and arrived 5-10 minutes early! They immediately greeted me and were very nice. I grabbed our food and took it back home. Unfortunately this was the first time ever that Poseidon's was not that great. The pizza was cold like it has been made right when I placed the order at 430. The thin crust was also PAPER thin and over cooked it seemed. Poseidons is usually very good! We will try it again in a couple weeks and give a new review!

Poseidons Pizza is hands down one of the best pizza joints located in the tri state. A definite go to for myself and family. Doesn’t give you that “chain” style food or vibes. Brad and Savannah have made us feel like family and the energy is contagious. Need more genuine people and establishments like Poseidons in the area! We’ve tried pretty much every pizza on the menu and all of them have been 🔥

We ordered the Deep Dish Sunday at MawMaw’s Pizza on a Friday night — our first time trying their deep dish style. We’ve definitely had Poseidon Pizza before and really like their regular pizzas, but this one was a little different for us. It’s heavy on the sauce, lighter on the toppings, with a fair amount of cheese. The flavor was good and interesting — not sure I’d get this particular pizza again since I’m not a big ricotta fan, but I’d definitely try their deep dish again in another variety. We really appreciate that Poseidon Pizza not only makes good food, but also gives back to the community. When we’re eating out or getting our Friday night pizza, they’re always in our rotation and a local favorite to support.

I ordered 2 large pizzas for my son’s birthday party, and spent $52 total including a tip, and 6 sauce cups. The pizza we received was the worst pizza I have ever seen and eaten. It does not resemble the photos the company advertises the food to look like, nor did it look appetizing. The crust was thin, hard and dry. The gooey cheese and warm sauce one would expect was not there. This pizza tasted and looked like it had been sitting out for days. I’m so disappointed and upset about the quality I got for spending $52 on 2 pizzas. It closely resembled cardboard with hard cheese. Our guests mentioned that did not enjoy it either and recommended Dominos for the next party!

Ordered the Deep Dish pizza which was delicious! Also ordered the cinnamon roll to try and it was rock hard and I realized it was made over a week ago (8 days old yuck) so that went into the trash. Otherwise then that we will definitely order more pizza in the future!