Porter Island Seafood Restaurant

Our Birthday outing for mom's birthday. Was exceptional. My steak was cooked to perfection, seasoned wonderfully. My husband ordered captain seafood platter. Seafood was cooked perfectly, great portions. Mom ordered hamburger steak dinner. She said it was delicious. Our server Jessica made sure our tea glasses stay filled. I would highly recommend this restaurant.

We were promptly seated. The dining area was clean, mostly. Our waitress Faith provided good service. We had the combination platter blackened with the grouper and crab cake added. The whipped garlic and chive butter they serve with captains wafers before your meal was a tasty treat. However, we could not bring ourselves to partake of the crab cake. It was like old bay flavored play dough.

We tried this place and had high hopes, but it really isn’t that good for the price. We got upcharged for credit card and they added on for getting the blackened option. So $6 added to our bill. Our sides were sad. The salad looked like a hospital salad , the greens were soupy not like pictures I seen online and definitely disappointing, the mashed potatoes tasted like box potatoes, and the cheese grits were aweful (so so thick and tasted strongly like artificial cheese). I think they were serving us margarine and calling it garlic butter as well. All my food was cold, except for the thick grits and the greens, I got blackened crab claws and oysters.. they were ok. Noone else at our table said theirs was cold though. The service was fine though, we had a very nice waitress. Ultimately I f

With the way I currently have to eat I had to change a few things and they were quick to accommodate my requests. And the food is amazing. Also the staff is very friendly.

What a cute little place! They take a lot of pride in keeping it very tidy and the service is very friendly. I had a large and delicious breakfast (standard fare). My wife enjoyed her seafood and sausage omelette. The coffee was hot and rich. If we lived closer, it would be our go to place for breakfast.