Plum Thickett Inn

What a Great Place! I loved my Italian Nachos, and was So impressed to see something so Unique on the menu! I got the Balsamic on the side, as I was unsure I would like it....but it was Amazing! Go for it!

This place was a lucky fine… Otherwise, there really was not much choice in the city. At first glance, it is quite offputting. That is, the sign out front looks like a sign for a business that went under 20 years ago, and the building itself looks a bit abandoned. Once you go in, however, it is an expensive small town restaurant… All the clientele knows the wait staff by first name, it would appear. The place really is quite pleasant. The food was solid, and made by hand quite clearly. All of us had the sirloin steak special… The steaks were tender and tasty, and the baked potato was done to the ideal point. In fact, it was quite a good meal, especially after a long day without one.

Friendly service country style atmosphere all American food.

Not too impressed. I went with a large storm chasing group (15 people), and I realize it can be a challenge to serve a group that big. However, our server kept forgetting who ordered which dishes and drinks. She asked for some of our names but didn’t ask for others’ names, which led to some confusion. As for the meal, I ordered steak, seasoned fries, and mashed potatoes with gravy. The fries were excellent. The mashed potatoes were pretty good, but portions were small. And the medium rare steak I ordered tasted more like medium. It wasn’t a bad meal by any means, but it could have been better.

Our waitress was very prompt with any needs, and made sure our order arrived timely as well. We also placed orders to go for others, and they made sure the order was ready and warm when we left, and dining in.