Pleasant Lake Cheesecake Company

I've been going here for years. Anytime I'm near New London or in New London I always have to stop and get a mini cheesecake at the very least. During the fall and winter time the gingerbread cheesecake is out of this world. The seasonal cheesecakes are flavors usually have I never had before. If you want to just stop by real quick and pick up some mini cheesecakes they always have some ready to purchase immediately. It was slim pickings today but still there were several options to choose from, so I managed to fill two boxes no problem. The mini cheesecakes I got today were salted caramel, strawberries and cream, cookies and cream, orange dream and blueberry. The cheesecake is homemade, nice and thick and is exactly how a cheesecake should taste. Fav place for sure!

I drove an hour from home when my mini me requested a cheesecake (no walmart or generic cheesecake would do, this kid has impeccable taste) for her birthday at the last minute. I was given an amazing array of options and they jumped into action! So polite and saved my day!

I have never been disappointed by the cheesecakes at Pleasant Lake Cheesecake Company! So much pride goes into making the cheesecakes look beautiful! I had a red velvet cheesecake and these sugar cookies made for my baby shower and I was so so pleased with how adorable they were, and super tasty! ♥️

Ordered a custom cake, it was beautiful and delicious. Exactly what I wanted and was able to be done on time! Lovely service.

There was a very small selection of whole cheesecakes, so we chose to get 4 mini cakes. We got a confetti one - which ended up being plain cheesecake with chocolate confetti topping, raspberry cream- which tasted again like plain cheesecake with raspberry on top, cookies and cream- really good, and a dark chocolate one- pretty good too. The raspberry one was slightly frozen on the inside which was strange , as if it had been in a freezer. Definitely too expensive for the size; each cheesecake, about 2 bite size, was almost $6. It was good, server was friendly, but It wouldn’t be at the top of my list