Plattsburgh Sourdough Co

Great bagels!!!! Loved the spicy everything bagel. A little spice but not overpowering. Lovely place to have an egg sandwich.

Came here because the google review seemed good. Walked in and immediately saw bagels that looked like they were a couple days old. I was planning on getting a sandwich on their fresh sourdough so I looked past it. They didn’t have very many options at all for sandwiches which seemed odd. Ordered a turkey club and they didn’t even use fresh bread. It had been pre sliced and when we got it, it seemed like bread from a couple days ago. We watched the sandwich being assembled and nothing was fresh. The turkey lived in a large bin and was not sliced fresh. It was slimy and wet when we got it. The orange cheddar cheese was so old it crumbled on the sandwich. They didn’t even have mustard to add to the sandwich and who we presume was the owner was unpleasant and unkind. The sandwich was immediat

I’m not quite sure how I feel about having enough cream cheese on a single bagel for two additional bagels. The giant mound was not really necessary and ended up in the trash. Bagels are good but… oof. They also didn’t add the bacon to the double meat sandwich, which is a main component of it so not sure what happened there.

Love the bagels here, best place to get them around

I asked for my bagel to be scooped and the owner very rudely told me no, he makes the bagels and won’t do that. My husband and I were in the food industry for many years. People have all kinds of dietary restrictions so we very taken aback by his response. My husband refrained from ordering anything. The owner was also talking negatively about other people to one of his employees. It didn’t feel like a very welcoming atmosphere and we won’t be back.