Pjs on the Bay

Amazing food! I was a little hesitant at first but that was quickly changed! Everything was so fresh and seasoned to perfection. I had to wait about 9 minutes but it was so worth the wait. The atmosphere was so welcoming. It felt like encountering family. One of the Chef’s/Owners was attentive and made sure the food was up to par and that I was satisfied. I’d go here for dinner or lunch every day if my wallet allowed it lol.

Reliable local pub! PJs on the Bay has tasty comfort food — the burger was juicy and well-seasoned, wings had great sauce, and the fish & chips were crispy. Service is friendly and quick, atmosphere is casual and welcoming (good spot to catch a game or unwind). Portions are generous, prices fair. Minor thing: can get loud on busy nights, but that's the pub charm. 4.5 stars — solid Sheepshead Bay hangout! What I got: burger, wings, fries. Highly recommend for casual eats and drinks!

We visited Pjs on the Bay for dinner on our way home from Coney Island since the traffic was really bad. We had their Oxtail with 2 sides: bean & rice and sautéed spinach and a single order of beef ribs. It’s overall delicious, especially the protein, which was cooked perfectly. The owners are super friendly and they treated us with fried chicken and empanadas to try. It’s impressively great, especially the crispy and juicy fried chicken.

Owner is really sweet, she gave me a sample of oxtail to try and she gave me a free soda. Mac and cheese wasn’t that great but the yams and oxtail was really good. Overall really good food

Excellent food. Went in a little early for the oxtails but they weren't ready. Went back later and they still weren't ready. The owner told me to go home and he would drop them off for me. That's exactly what he did. Glad I waited. They were right on the money. Rasta pasta is outstanding, greens were money as well as everything else. Owners are sweethearts too. So glad I came in and gave you guys a try. Will definitely be back with Mookie. Lol. Came in tonight and picked up 2 orders of wings, sides included. How beautiful does this food look?