Pizza Cottage

This Pizza Cottage was a classic pizza place. It was close to the end of this year. The dining room was decorated with lovely Christmas decorations. There were also many screens for games, a good bar, and a private room inside. Service was great. WiFi was fast. I ordered a classic meat pizza with thin crust. It tasted fresh and authentic, but was too oily. There were everyday specials and holiday events. Definitely a great sport bar or party place.

I have been eating at pizza cottage for over 20 years.I ordered a salad 3 weeks ago from the Pickerington location. The salad only had 4 pepperoni on it. I ordered 2 pizza on 11/16/15 one pizza was pepperoni, onions and peppers. When I tell you these green peppers and onions are so damn thin, you can barely taste them in the pizza, and they look like string. I won’t be returning, I’ll find another local establishment.

A regular customer for many years and generally love the food here . However last evening our pizza was a disappointment substandard for this establishment.😞... supposed to be half pepperoni half ham with pineapple. The toppings were minimal except overabundance of pineapple. Crust was chewy, had hardly any sauce with a sloppy thrown together appearance. We attempted to eat it, but each piece seemed to be no better than the one before. When the waitress asked if we wanted a box, my husband and I both said NO! We normally don't complain. But I told her the pizza really wasn't good at all. She apologized and came back with a changed receipt, giving us credit for the pizza. This was nice but what we wanted was to eat a good pizza . That is why we went there to begin with.

I wanted to try Pizza Cottage in Pickerington after three years, so today I ordered a thin-crust pizza. I was excited when I opened the box—there were plenty of mushrooms and tomatoes. YAY. The excitement was short-lived. The crust tasted like cardboard, and I didn’t like the sauce either. Oh well, back to my favorite pizza place…

We had a birthday party there for our grandson last weekend and we were in the 1st party room. The room had bad stench to it like a real smell mop was used, and the floor was sticky in areas. The pizza was decent and this was my first time ever in a pizza cottage. The server was nice and always kept our drinks full and was always friendly and there for our needs.