Picos Taco Shack

Our new favorite stop in Brewster! I love heading to the beaches here, and I’m always looking for great food to bring along. We stopped at Picos over the weekend on our way to the beach, and it was such a good decision. Ordering was quick and easy, and the space itself is great—an open kitchen with indoor tables, plus plenty of outdoor seating on the covered deck and patio. I can only imagine how lively it gets on summer days. We went in late September, and the food was fantastic. Every order comes with hot tortilla chips and salsa, which is AMAZING and the perfect beach fuel. We also noticed a lot of bikers stopping in from the nearby rail trail, so it’s clearly a popular spot. The drinks menu looked awesome too! We all ordered burritos—fish, chicken, steak, and veggie - and every single

I rarely (if ever) leave a review but this Taco Shack warranted a 5 star review. The Baja Cod tacos were awesome - lightly battered in a light oil - not heavily breaded and thick with oil like many spots. The taste was superb, and the experience was great because they cater to bikers and we could pull off the rail trail, stay with our bikes, and enjoy a nice lunch.

First visit. Small little shed, really. I think my living room is bigger. Parties of 4, 5, 6 in line with and without kids. Obvious tourists. Meh. Ordered a pork burrito without guac (I hate guac and dont understand the fascination with avocado at all) and without black beans. They dont have refried. Added corn. They forgot the pico i guess. Decent sized, but nothing that would make me come back. The chips were tastless and the salsa was runny with no chunk. I also ordered Mexican street corn which was tasty, but i prefer fresh or frozen corn, and I expected something less watery, as I've experienced at other spots, and it didnt look like the pics on their menu. I should have asked. To finish things off, I got a frozen white peach margarita, which was just my speed. It was the most enjoya

10/10 best tacos ever. We stopped here after a bike ride down the CCRT, and weren’t disappointed. We had the avocado bites, nachos, and burritos. They also brought out a huge thing of chips with AMAZING salsa. We will be back, probably multiple times this trip.

There is ramp access, the burger was so delicious and had this very uniquely seasoned cabbage on top, which was very tasty! I forget that I need to tell people not to grill my burger bun because I like it soft and not crunchy with butter, but other than that, it was very tasty It was about $15 but for the size of the burger that was a decent price I think and it came with a massive supply of french fries. The servers were very friendly, there is plenty of seating indoors and out of every type, there’s a bathroom that’s very clean, and there is a beanbag toss game outside!