Pete's Subs

I haven't been here in almost 10 years and let me say, that's changing immediately. The inside has doubled in size since I was last there and there is now a decent amount of tables to eat. I tried their pork roll egg and cheese sub and it was fantastic. Everybody at the store was super nice and friendly, it made for a great experience.

We ordered a special Italian hoagie on Super Bowl Sunday. This may be the best hoagie we have ever had. The roll was very good with plenty of meat in it. We now know why people were coming and going to pick-up orders. Very good!

Had the cheesesteak with extra meat, lettuce, tomato, mayonnaise, onions. Agree with the other reviewer that some seasoning on the meat would help but it was still tasty. Fries were delicious. My wife’s Meatball Parm sub was REALLY good. Going with that next time!

I ordered 1 whole Italian sub, a half of chicken cheese steak a chicken fingers with fries combo and an extra order of fries and a 2 liter Pepsi and was charged $60. I got a receipt with the just the price. Unless the online menu prices are outdated on the website, I got overcharged pretty good. Although the food was great, I can't pay that much anymore. It was my 1st time there. I purchased the same food at Vicks and never paid close to that much. Don't get me wrong, the food was excellent, but I now have reservations about going back there again.

My expectations were set way too high for this place. I remember when this place first opened, the t-shirts they made were very controversial to some. The shirt said “you wouldn’t let Michael Jackson watch your kids, why would you let a pizza place make your sub?”. Everyone told me to get the meatball sub, so I did. I think I pinched a nerve shrugging at the mediocrity of the sub. I heard such praise but was disappointed. Meatballs were big, sauce was good but was dumped on top, nearly impossible to eat without looking like Carrie in the gymnasium scene. Soggy soggy soggy. There’s no chance of eating this without it turning to mush. Meatballs had no flavor and were grey. Was it a chicken meatball? Was this an off day? I could see people loving it but I’d rather have quality over quantity,