Pennington Pizza & Grill

Would highly recommend— the simple outside appearance leads into a delicious wonderland; the food is insanely good. Firstly, in assessing their basic cheese pizza quality compared to 27+ local pizzerias, they scored #1, due to their chewy crust, gooey cheese, and satisfying overall experience. Secondly, they have a range of iconic types of pizza, such as Tortellini Alfredo, my personal favorite. Lastly, their pastas are also tasty and have worked well for catering. A must go!

Cute little hole in the wall. Needs a good cleaning. Napkin holders were gross & most tables were dirty. Cheeseburger Sub was missing Os, burger was over cooked… 1 half of the sub had oregano on it 🤗. Buffalo Chicken Pizza was good, Mozzarella Sticks good. Marinara ehhh.

I ate here today with family, the food was absolutely amazing, very fresh, and worth every penny. When we sat down, the waiter came right over to care for us and we were very impressed to say the least. I had a personal plain pizza with bacon that could not have not tasted any better. This will be the new spot for us to meet up when we want some good Italian favorites! Job well done on everything, the stars I have given are so well deserved!!

Pizza places are abundant in NJ but this one stands out for me. I eat here often as this is where my extended family gathers for a meal a few times a month. I've tried several different menu items and every single one has stood out as better then most other pizza shops. The bread basket that gets put on the table even...the bread is the best! Bertha has been our server every time we come and she is absolutely lovely. We will continue to gather here for the delicious food and nice staff.

Classic pizzeria. The staff are very friendly and they work as fast as they can! The place can get busy, especially on popular days (like Friday night). We've enjoyed emerging from pizza to sandwiches, burgers,, fries, meatballs, wings... it's all very good! The pizza sauce is a little sweeter than other places, which I love (but may not be for everyone). Prices are still reasonable and you can get a large pie for under $20