Penn Station East Coast Subs

Let me start off by saying if I could give zero stars I would! I called in a pickup order and the person who answered asked me to repeat everything I said about 3 times which was annoying. When my boyfriend went inside to pickup the food he said the workers were unfriendly. We received a bag soaked through with grease (pictured below). The smell when he brought the food into the car was absolutely nauseating. The fries were definitely undercooked and extremely greasy, the subs were also a grave disappointment. My boyfriend ordered a large sub and could only manage to take two bites of it from how revolting it tasted. This is extremely upsetting and I would NEVER recommend it to anyone, it’s even more upsetting because we aren’t from here and just wanted to try something new. Also it was $3

This is my favorite Penn Station location! The team is always friendly when you come in. They’re very nice about custom or special orders. They never skimp on the toppings or fries. I’ve ordered online, in person, I’ve dined in, gotten it to go and dined in with my special needs/handicapped family member. Always a great experience. And this spot has a cool unique view!

The night staff (9 pm) on 11/22/2025 at this Westfield location should get a raise for the level of care they put into my family’s food order. They were friendly when I called my order in, took time to make our food orders when we arrived, and these are the best sandwiches I have ever had since I have ordered at this location. Excellent service and highly recommend! Way to go Penn Station staff!

I recently had the pleasure of dining at Penn Station in Westfield, Indiana, and I must say that the experience exceeded all expectations. One of the standout features was the genuinely kind and helpful staff. From the moment I walked in, their friendly demeanor and willingness to assist created a welcoming and comfortable environment. What truly impressed me was the speed of their service. Despite the busy lunch rush, my order was prepared and served promptly without compromising on quality. The efficiency demonstrated their commitment to ensuring a seamless and enjoyable dining experience. The welcoming atmosphere further enhanced the visit. The restaurant's clean and inviting layout, coupled with the friendly interactions between staff and patrons, made me feel like a valued guest. A

This is one of our family's most favorite restaurants. Being from Indiana, we're obviously not from the east coast, however the food seems extremely authentic. The Philly Cheesesteak is what we get every single time, especially when the ghost pepper promotion is going on. During the Pacer's Playoff run, they run even more promotions with free food. Fast and consistent. Can't recommend highly enough.