Peggy Jean's Pies

I've been going here on and off for a year now... VERY hit or miss. They do not par bake their pie crusts... so the quiche and some of the cream pies are soggy and gross. It's too bad their taste is good but the crust is slimy and disgusting. IF it's a pie they don't need to par bake it tastes great. PAR BAKE YOUR PIE CRUSTS PLEASE!!!!!

Best place in Columbia for homemade pies of two sizes and all types of fabulous flavors made homemade every day so get there while they still have some. We selected a German chocolate, blackberry, and peach praline in the small pies. Then, I especially stopped to bring some of their savory pot pies home. The southwest chicken, the buffalo chicken, and my favorite pot roast pot pie. If you've never tried this place I highly recommend it when you're in town or you live in town. Support your locally-owned businesses so we keep them in our communities.

We have gotten pies many times and they are always very good. This time we got a caramel apple and a French Chocolate silk pie. Both tasted very good. One place we almost always go to when we get up to Columbia. Taste like pies your mom, aunt or grandma would make or any other favorite relative. Yum!!!

BEST pies in CoMo! We treat ourselves on holidays, birthdays, special occasions, and when our family visits. Now when I make trips to my mom’s home in Hannibal, she requests that I bring her a Peggy Jeans Coconut Cream pie. We haven’t had a pie choice we didn’t like. My fav’s are the German Chocolate & the Strawberry. Friendly & helpful staff too. Now I want some pie after writing this review.

I’ve eaten their pies for years and always been pleased with their quality and the service of their staff. But I want to take a minute and thank them for their recent help. My mom had just received a diagnosis that gave her new dietary restrictions. I called and asked what things I could order given those restrictions and they found us a delicious lemon pie. To top it off, they even called back to double check if eggs were ok because we hadn’t discussed that possibility. I was touched by their efforts and encourage anyone who hasn’t popped by to give them a try! Also, their pie tasting is very fun!