Pegasus Coffee House

A cute little coffee shop off the main strip. Pegasus is clearly a local favorite by how busy it was midday on a Thursday! I could see them getting so busy the line would snake out the door, so we were lucky to sneak in before the crowd and order one of their specialty drinks, a cardamom latte! The drink tasted authentic, not using artificial syrups or sugar. We would have loved to stay and enjoy the cozy ambiance, but we had more of the island to explore.

Such a nice and quaint place to stop for coffee. The atmosphere feels cozy and welcoming, and the coffee itself is really good. It was packed when I went, but definitely worth the wait. A great spot to relax and enjoy the island vibe. Would absolutely visit again.

Such a cute little coffee shop. Very quaint and cozy. I tried the pumpkin pie latte. One of the best lattes I’ve ever had. Wasn’t overly sweet and syrupy. You could really taste the quality. My husband had black coffee and he said that it was a very good brew. We both ordered breakfast. The food was good, not great.

One of the best cofOne of the best coffee places I have ever been. The different coffees we ordered (cappuccino, machiato and cortado) were genuinely good. The food was also surprisingly tasty and the deserts took it to next level.

I’m definitely coming back here! Such a cute stop on our trip to Bainbridge! Amazing ivy growing up the building mixed with the brick. Good coffee and maple donuts! Seating is minimal but we got lucky when it wasn’t busy.