Papa Romeo's Pizza Chicago Lincoln Park

Honestly, this is the best pizza I’ve ever had. 🍕 I’ve tried pizza in many cities and even different countries, but nothing compares to Papa Romeo’s. You can truly taste the difference. They use top-quality ingredients and a special recipe that makes every slice stand out. The flavor is rich, the crust is perfect, and everything tastes fresh. If you love real, high-quality pizza, you need to try this place. One bite and you’ll understand.

Barebones place with two small tables if you want to eat in. This place does not sell pizza by the slice despite what some other reviews say. It was decent noting to come back for unfortunately. Medium margarita pizza is $23 for carry out. We found the pizza to be sweet and not memorable. Wanted to get wings as well but the wait would have been 25 minutes and we did not realize that it would have ordered ahead of time.

Seems like a brand new restaurant. Very very clean. Even more polite and friendly staff. Food looks and smells amazing and can’t wait to try it! (Will update review when I do.) This is absolutely a place worth checking out! Owner was very friendly and polite while hubby and I figured out what we wanted and again when we totally started to order the wrong thing. 🤦‍♀️🤣 Food was done pretty quickly (20-30mins) and was reasonably priced. We ordered a large deep dish meat lovers and a 14”hand tossed whatever their “supreme” is (junior combo maybe?) Got garlic bread to go with it too!

Delicious, delicious food! Amazing customer service, delivery right on time. Best of all, my delivery person was incredibly friendly and grateful for the business.

We had been eagerly waiting for Papa Romeo’s to open, and it was well worth the wait—finally got to try their pizza and it was delicious! We’re so happy to have another great pizza option in the neighborhood. We didn’t realize they had already opened, so we do wish there had been a bit more advertising or buzz. That said, don’t let that stop you from checking them out. Support local—especially when it tastes this good!