Papa Johns Pizza

I've been happy with my past orders but not the most recent (the 1st week of 2026). I knocked off 2 stars for this. One pizza had a large bubble which sank and is missing cheese and toppings. The other is stuffed crust-it's overcooked and cardboard thin and flimsy. I feel scammed.

I order here quite often and the fact that I call to complain about my pizza not having any alfredo sauce on it and the person who answered the phone wants to argue with me saying she did but refused for me to bring it in for proof. Here is the proof. Do better. Just a simple apology and a redue would of been better than what I recieved

I think some people are just overly critical. Leaving a 5 paragraph review because you didn't get pickles? Put that energy into chopping up some pickles yourself and putting it on your pizza. People want to get worked up over the smallest nothing things. Every time I order pizza from here I am satisfied. Sometimes it's not as good as other times but that is life. I think people need to have realistic expectations for pizza as I do LOL. No other pizza chain makes my stomach as happy and full as Papa Johns does! Staff here are very nice and my pizza is always nice and hot! I will say on a final note the customers at this location need to learn how to park! Too many people want to block the front of the business with their cars because they are too lazy to walk 10 feet from a parking lot to

We almost always get pizza on Wednesday. We were a little concerned when the people who worked at this Papa John's moved on. Brandon, the new manager, has ensured that the quality of the pizza and the friendliness of the staff stayed consistent. We have a Papa John's closer to us but we will continue to pick up our pizza at this location. Plus the parmesan garlic chicken wings are amazing!

1 star only. This is for the chain overall but the photos are from this location. The one at Wells Rd. also mangled the same pizza when I ordered last week (which is also why I switched locations) but I didn't take photos. Just tired of ordering pizza online, paying full price, and still getting low-quality food. This time the pizza was missing pickles. WHY did the chain make the pizza if they were out (presumably) of an ingredient? Why didn't they call me to inform me and allow me the opportunity to choose a different pizza? When I picked up, neither employee said a word about missing toppings, so I grabbed my pizza and went on my way. How disappointing to open the box and not see any pickles. Mellow Mushroom did the same thing and I quit giving them my business - check my review if you