Papa Johns Pizza

I live right across the street, and this is one of the life saving stores! I love the pizzas from here! Been ordering it almost every 10 days once. Also, try their brownie as well, it’s one of the best that I ever had. ( order online with the app, you get many offers and better price)

I have ordered from this location a couple times over the past years & went tonight to try the new , limited time garlic stuffed crust. The customer service to pick up the food was pretty good, the guy getting my pizza and giving it to me was friendly and through to make sure I got the right order. The garlic stuffed crust was not amazing , but it was not bad.

I’ve order from here at least 3 times recently and every time they’ve gotten my order right and it has come quick and taste amazing don’t know why it has bad reviews I say give them a try I love them !

How it’s possible I order a pizza and the pizza was raw and I called to report this they were useless and the only thing they told me was to return the pizza the my family ate without realizing it was raw. The pizzas before have been amazing.

There was easy parking in the evening by the store. However, parking in the downtown of New Rochelle is horrible. Meters are in effect even pass midnight, and on top of the metters being complicated, they are usually broken. So I had to take my chances while parking. The service was fast and polite, the only thing I didn't like was that the credit card reader requires you to add tip on top, and I wasn't able to choose the amount I wanted to add. Had to cancel the payment process and pay in cash. Most pizzerias in the area closed by 9:30-10:00, so it good that Papa John's stays open until 1:00 AM. The pizza was great, came with excellent garlic sauce and one hot pepper on the side. Small pizza that is enough for 2 people cost about $7 before tax.