Outlaw Oyster

Incredible atmosphere, fantastic oysters and great food! I will absolutely be back here. We came on a Friday night, no reservations needed, oyster specials for their ‘yappy hour’, the lobster roll was delicious and hot, not creamy which was a relief and not filled with shrimp, only lobster. They’re owned by Crafty Cow which is wild because it’s such a different vibe but totally worth it! Loved the service, the food and the atmosphere. Come here for a unique

This was everything I wanted it to be! They started us with a wine sipper which is so nice and also an amazing way to try new stuff. We got the espresso tini tinis which were SO delish and properly strong. We got one of each featured oyster- all fantastic and the aguachili was a great addition. The smoked trout plate was deliiiiiish and so satisfying. We also got the lobster sliders, smaller than expected but yummy. The Cesar fries are a worthwhile upgrade for sure. I got an extra dry dirty martini and it was perfect. Our waiter Emma was so helpful and kind and fun. We spent the whole dinner talking about how we can’t wait to come back!!!!

We went to the bayview location a few weeks ago. We arrived right when they opened at 2pm. We were the only ones there from the time we stepped in to when we left. Ordered a dozen oysters to start and it took over 30 minutes to get to us. For something that doesnt require cooking, thats crazy to even think about. Because it took so long, I requested that they put in our main order asap because we didnt want to wait even longer for that to arrive. We ordered the XL lobster roll. MORE LIKE XS LOBSTER ROLL! We expected the image on their website which looked like a regular sized lobster roll. The bread was half the size. If the "XL" came from the size of the lobster, I guarantee you that the amount of lobster inside the roll is not equivalent to the 1 large lobster. Overall our bill came out

I think this is my new favorite restaurant in Milwaukee. They have a great selection of wine and even have skin contact wine (which is a must try) The menu is cultivating, interesting, and refreshing. The tin fish options are phenomenal and always rotating and the oysters are *chef’s kiss*. The oysters are fresh and delicate in the palate. I would recommend everyone giving it a try (even if it’s a little scary if you haven’t tried oysters)

This place is so awesome; rotating oysters. Great happy hour deals. So fresh & creative! There are tiny Tinies ( dirty and espresso) for $3. Wednesday’s are 2-3$ oysters, and great appetizer deals after 8:30. It’s definitely girl dinner approved.