Otto's

There's not much to say except you need to eat here. The chicken sandwich, it was so good. It has some kind of crispy crust on it that is awesome The Taste was unbelievable and the girl said it was made with a gluten-free coating. My husband loved the burrito it had all kinds of things in it. And for such a small place it is just so cute. Enjoy!

We rarely eat at the same restaurant twice in one day but that’s exactly what we did at Otto’s. Breakfast sandwiches and hash browns were amazing (all with gluten-free options) and when we came back for an early dinner, maybe the best fried chicken sandwich we’ve ever had; and gluten free too! Also, the French fries were delicious and the staff is amazing.

We stopped here to dodge Breckenridge traffic after skiing. Man, are we glad we did! The people here were very welcoming. We said we wanted to eat each other's sandwich and breakfast burritos so they split it for us! So tasty, very big portion, very filling. We had the breakfast burrito and Cajun chicken sandwich, both amazing.

Otto’s Sandwich Shop in Fairplay is an absolute gem! The sandwiches are fresh, generously portioned, and packed with flavor—clearly made with quality ingredients and real care. The bread is excellent, the meats and veggies are fresh, and everything tastes homemade rather than rushed. The shop has a cozy, welcoming vibe that fits perfectly with the mountain-town feel, and the service is friendly and genuine. Whether you’re passing through or a local, Otto’s is the kind of place you’ll want to come back to. Easily one of the best spots in Fairplay for a satisfying, delicious meal.

Dude, this place is SO ridiculously good. I am vegetarian and my best friend has celiac so there are very limited options for us. We are both taken aback by how delicious this food is. I got the veggie griller and it is so good that I am taking a pause to write a review. Also the GF bun is phenomenal. This never happens for us!! Allison is awesome!! So kind and so cool!!! Give her a raise 💯💯💯💯Emo queen