OTB Cafe - Old Town Bagels

We were driving through the area and stopped here for a snack. The staff was nice and welcoming and I like the design of the place, except which register to order at is a tad confusing. The sign said to order at one register but the girls told us to order at the ice cream counter. We got the butterscotch latté at half-sweetness, a cold brew, and an asiago bagel, toasted, with plain cream cheese. The drinks took a little longer than we're used to, and I had to ask how much more time we needed to wait on the bagel cause we needed to get back on the road. Time stamps say we waited 15 minutes on the bagel with only one person who ordered before us. The latté was also fine, but the cold brew tasted like straight mud. It was so bitter and there was so much sediment that my husband went to the ba

Great bagel, with great atmosphere, and delightful friendly, freckled Midwestern service! Lovely place. Busy on Sat morning, but didn’t take long, and crowd was enjoying it. One tip: order the toasted kitchen sink bagel, skip the sun-dried tomato and go all in on the Olive Pimento. 10/10 would be back!

OTB is the best! Great staff, excellent food and the who place just feels incredibly cozy and small town. If you are in the area, it’s a must visit! Here’s my cookie dough ice cream and coffee. I love the bagels (obv) and the sandwiches are excellent!

We were in town for a wedding on July 15th, 2023. We decided to opt out of the free breakfast at our hotel to try the nice little Bagel Shop just a few steps from our hotel. As cam inside the shop was buzzing with a nice cool atmosphere. We put our order in and found a table. 10-15 minutes go buy and we see multiple orders coming out that was behind ours. We went to the counter after 15 min to see if there was an issue and boy did things go down hill fast. They claimed they had no record of our order and wanted us to reorder and pay again!! We had a number they gave us for our order and table!! I told them we have a restaurant and use the Square POS system as well. It’s very simple to pull it back up just using your name. Once they figured out I was more knowledgeable than them, they ju

Always fresh and delicious. Try something new each time and have yet to be disappointed. The cream cheese is so lite and fluffy and mouthwatering, then pair it with a fresh bagel and it’s the perfect way to start a day or indulgence your tastebuds for lunch. The shop is so cute and friendly and comfy. Staff is always upbeat and when you can’t decide they can help choose a great option. Love this place!!