Osteria Procaccini

This is my go to place for pizza in Pennington, NJ. It's my go to place for several reasons: 1. The pizza is a thin crust that is baked in the oven and absolutely delicious. It's crisp, yet doughy. It's got that nice smoky flavor from the crumbles in the oven, but does not taste burnt. 2. All of their ingredients always taste so fresh. Their sausage, you can taste the fennel, their tomato sauce, you can taste the tomatoes. Their peppers taste like peppers. Their mushroom pizzas have the essence of mushroom in them. The flavors vibrate. 3. This place is very popular. Sometimes the service isn't the quickest but the food is definitely fresh and worth the wait. I'd plan to make it a nice dinner here instead of a rush in and dine kind of place. Have a drink. Get an appetizer. Laugh

Recommend this place as the pizza is a bit different from the usual places around here. We had ordered the mustard pie, which was one of the best in the area. Our service was attentive, but for some reason they lacked most of the beer that we wanted for some reason. Would not stop me from re-visiting. Nice outdoor seating area also available, which is wonderful with weather permitting.

Food is awesome but it's the service that makes this place better than just good. Tonight my car wouldn't start and someone who worked in the restaurant came out in the freezing cold to help me. It reminds me that there are good people in the world. Thank you!

Visiting nearby and decided to try this place out back in early December based on a recommendation. Must have been an off night as the food took forever and the table next to us was very aggravated and unhappy with their food when they did eventually get it. We were debating on leaving too until we finally got our appetizers. Despite our growing aggravation, we very much enjoyed our appetizers of garlic knots, roasted potatoes, and burrata and figs. Pasta entrees were good too. It was also nice that they were able to make a dairy free pasta dish for my one dining companion who has a dairy allergy. Menu was limited at the time and I think they were going through changes, so hopefully they have since rectified and improved.

Their pizza is very good. We did the make your own style. Their crust is neither big nor thin, just in between. The sauce and toppings are just right. They should call Dave portney to get a score, it will come under 8.4 or so. Friendly staff, kids everywhere, nice atmosphere. Good family place for dinner etc.