OSM Eats

I'd give this place seven stars if I could. You can feel the care and thought that goes into this place. We chatted with the chef/cashier for a bit and he was very friendly and genuine. We ordered a large pan vegan pizza. Vegan cheese is often gluey and untasteful, but their homemade version is great! If I come back to Whidbey this will be one of my first stops! It's also worth noting that there is no indoor seating.

Best pizza on the Island... Nah, best pizza in all of Western Washington! The vegan menu is robust and filled with wonderful tasty meal options and treats. And the cookie, lordy the cookie! Bucolic setting with outside tables and plenty of space for the littles to run about and dog friendly! Highly recommend stopping by for lunch if you're on the Island on a Saturday or Sunday. Fyi, Farmers market is open on Sundays.

The pizza was good. Better than most you can find in the area. But not 10$ a slice good. If it was like 3-5 dollars a slice this would be 5 stars all day but you can find better pizza and certainly not leave wanting to find something else to eat. I really wanted to love it and the service and atmosphere was nice but even in 2024 10 dollars for a slice of pizza is highway robbery. Edit: the slices are indeed ~8 dollars but I'll always tip regardless of price which brings the total to 10.

I have had OSM's slices during the farmers market on Sundays, but today was the first time I stopped by when there wasn't the market, and it was just perfect. I took my mom and my two little boys. We had the place to ourselves and I don't think we could have had a more awesome pizza dining experience. First of all, their pizza is phenomenal. We got a 16" half pesto, half veggie (they only do slices for the market) and two kombuchas for about $40. It's a thicker thin crust. My son, who is not yet two, had never liked olives until he had them on an OSM pizza. The crust is just the right amount of chewy, not too crispy kind. The rest is juicy, but not too messy, with the right amount of melted cheese ooze. It's savory and salty and oh so delicious! If they're open, just stop reading and go

Excellent pizza! The flavor was great. We rolled up and put in our order, and the very friendly server said we could wait in our car... But it smelled so good we stayed put!