One Pie Pizza Co

20/10 on the gluten-free crust!! On my gluten-free journey, I am always eager to want to try pizza from a lot of different places. Im not settling on the flat thin crust or cauliflower. It’s good yeah, but when you think of pizza that is just not it. If I could order just the dough with the garlic butter on it I could eat just that. Just wow 🤤

Visiting the One Pie Pizza Co. is a must when we go to Buffalo for Sabres games. This is for sure the best pizza I’ve ever eaten. I’d be here a few times a week if I didn’t live so far away. I’ve had the pepperoni pie and the pepperoni/ricotta/hot honey. Both solid choices in their own way and both cooked perfectly. The edges of the cup n char pepperoni are crispy. Dough is amazing. Sauce is perfect. Wish there was table service or even better options for seating if you want to eat in. There’s one small table for 2 in the corner and a counter to sit at but seating is very limited. 10/10 Would repeat!

Had their March special of the month, Rueben pizza and a traditional cheese pepp, added onions and banana peppers - everything was delicious

Tried the pizza here recently and it’s a new family favorite. We have been hooked on the Hot Honey Ricotta with light sauce. It’s so good. So is the breakfast pizza and 3 little pigs. Great service too always ready when they say it will be done , hot and tasty. Cannoli is pretty good too.

Best pizza in WNY. Top quality ingredients and consistent product every purchase. Never disappointed. Clean establishment and friendly staff.