On The Bay Boutique, Bar & Cafe

I love On the Bay because the tropical atmosphere takes you to a Key West oasis whether it is summer or winter outside! The drink menu includes many delicious cocktail options, and their food menu includes some tasty features, including lobster Mac and cheese and key lime pie! They’ve added on a bigger bar section on the inside for more seating, but they also have heated enclosed tents outside. Located in downtown New Baltimore, this is a perfect place to stop for beverage and shop their cute boutique items!

This was our first time eating at On The Bay and all I can say is WOW. The bartender, Steve, was so nice. We told him it was our first time there & he went over the menu with us, and told us what they were known for, and also his favorites. We had a fruity, frozen drink & a coffee drink, and both were really good. My fiancé got the lobster bisque & loved it. We shared the lobster ravioli for an appetizer, it was absolutely delicious, & I could have drank the sauce it was so good. For our entrees we got the braised short ribs, and the Mahi Mahi, and both were super yummy. The short ribs were sooo tender & that pineapple, mango salsa on the Mahi Mahi really went well with the fish, and gave it that extra kick. Even though it was our first time there, the staff made us feel like regulars,

We celebrated our 15th wedding anniversary tonight to enjoy the best fresh and amazing foods. We shared the huge pretzel and pub cheese, a pound of amazing mussels and the freshest lobster tacos with a pineapple mango salsa. We also enjoyed the outdoor atmosphere with the cool evening and no more bees!!! Our server was so friendly and gracious and was very impressive. We will definitely be back soon for some sun, fun and great food!

NYE, was our first time here but definitely won’t be our last! From start to finish, it was a great experience! Molly was our server, she is super sweet and extremely helpful. The food was delicious! We had lots hater bisque soup and the spicy lobster and shrimp dip to start, yum yum bubblegum! Our rice bowls, lobster ravioli, burger and flatbread did not disappoint!!!! Such a cute place, it’s small but welcoming. Can’t wait to go back!

This is usually one of our favorite spots in New Baltimore. Today, we order carry out. Two Jumbo Pretzels, The Bacon Jam Burger, Shrimp Rice Bowl, and a Cuban Sandwich (the first time ever ordering the Cuban). The Pretzel is a must! It's HUGE, and it never disappoints! The Bacon Jam Burger is my husband's favorite! A hint of sweet & spicy. The shrimp bowl is very filling, and the flavors come together very well. The Cuban Sandwich was very disappointing. The pulled pork was pretty much missing on the sandwich. I am attaching photos for reference. When we opened the sandwich, we laughed at the lack of meat that was on it. The bread was very good but we would order this again. Even though we did carryout today, we have dined in many times and would definitely recommend it. The atmo