Old Town Pizzeria & Tap House

I love this place. It’s shot an hour away from where I live, but I make my way. It’s just a few minutes from church so that’s a plus. They have the best smoked ribs I’ve had on this Island, so far. I just wish they offered more variety of sides, like maybe some Green Beans, Greens, Corn On The Cob.

🍕 Back for More—and Still Supreme! 🌟 After a great first impression, we couldn’t resist coming back to this pizzeria—and once again, they nailed it. The supreme pizza was a masterpiece…again…loaded with savory meats, crisp veggies, and just the right amount of melty cheese, all resting on a perfectly baked crust that had us reaching for slice after slice. The atmosphere? Still effortlessly cool. Casual, laid-back, and welcoming—like your favorite pair of slippers but with better lighting and the scent of fresh pizza in the air. Whether you’re catching up with friends or just craving a top-tier pie, this spot delivers comfort and flavor in equal measure. Already planning our next visit. Maybe we’ll try the baby back ribs!

Came here for lunch, adequate parking in the back area. Ordered two pizzas, a meat lovers and the margarita. Not to mention they were very accommodating with the extra jalapeños. Good relaxing atmosphere and the staff were all courteous and friendly. Family crowd, something here for everyone.

I ordered a slice of pizza for something quick and easy, but it was so disappointing. The slice was completely drenched in grease by the time it hit the table, it looked like it was sitting in a pool of oil. It was soggy and had a bad taste to it. Definitely not something I’d come back for.

Matt gave us a true lay of the land with a genuine local perspective—great conversation and even better hospitality. He took the time to point out other local shops and favorites in the area, which really added to the experience. You can tell the food is prepared with real care and pride in the kitchen. The garlic knots were perfectly done, evenly coated in a fresh, flavorful garlic sauce that tasted homemade. The Meat Lovers pizza was crispy with an excellent balance and variety of meats—rich, satisfying, and full of flavor. The Old Town Tiki was also a great touch to round out the meal. Hands down, this place delivers genuine care and standout service. We’ll be telling everyone to come experience it for themselves.