Old Town Cafe

The food is just okay and the cost to eat here is outrageous! Forty bucks for two burgers with fries! The menu shows the price as $14.95 each so you're paying $5.05 per burger in "taxes & fees"! That's 34%! The burgers are prepattied and the fries get soggy before you can eat them. The main dishes are cafeteria style food at best. Veggies are canned or frozen. The really aggravating thing about this establishment and the main reason I will avoid it in the future is the fact that they just take your money without even asking! There are fees on all card transactions so you want to pay cash. Then they just give you back whatever they want, deducting a significant gratuity. I always tip but it should be up to me what I give! Even on a take out order, you wondering why your change was short com

Started off bad. We were promptly seated but took forever to get a server. Servers running around but not really organized. People waiting for checks, paying, and food took forever. When the server finally arrived she was very rude. Saying "what do you want" we ordered our drinks and ordered food at the same time since it had been so long. When she brought the drinks she forgot my ice water and I politely said I had an ice water too and her reply was "I only have two hands" . My wife had coffee and after drinking the first cup I placed her cup at the edge of the table and no one ever refilled while I counted 11 passes by our table by servers. I finally stopped one and asked for a refill they brought it but did not say a word even though I said thank you. One note is people that came in way

Ordered chicken tenders and a chicken sandwich, they have taken our customized order for sandwich and it was yumm! Have got fries as well along with our servings, their secret sauce is a must try. Good ambience and staff were friendly.

We stayed in West Yellowstone for three days and ended up coming to Old Town Cafe every single day — that’s how much we loved it! The food was consistently amazing — we tried the bison burger with waffle fries, huckleberry lemonade, and chicken wings, and everything tasted absolutely delicious. The place has great music and a fun, welcoming vibe — really captures that relaxed West Yellowstone energy. The staff were friendly, the portions generous, and it quickly became our favorite spot in town. Highly recommend stopping by if you’re in the area!

Had dinner here. One of the more popular restaurant. Place was packed. Order elk medallion and fish & chips. Food was ok - no real wow factor. First they got the salad wrong and it was hard to get the server. Many people hanging out behind the wall at the kitchen instead of standing on the main floor. Many had their eyes down and not observing patrons. Was hard to get their attention.