Old Cutler Inn

I visited Old Cutler Inn for brunch and this was my first time visiting it. The brunch is priced $50 p/p and you have the option to add unlimited mimosas or bellinis for $25 per adult. Food was good, but I wish they had more variety to choose from. Their buffet area is kind of small and they also have a menu to order some items á la carte. Service needs some improvement. I will go back in the future to give them another chance.

I went to the bar outside only. But the wait was a little long for the amount of people that were there. We had to actually waive the bartender down. And said ohh I’m sorry didn’t see you 300lbs 6.2’ bright red shirt is hard to miss. But whatever. She ended up recommending some drinks which we like and I actually fell in love with one that will be my new go to drink there. Amber honey mash totally recommend. Tina I believe was her name ended up being amazing. Explaining every drink and and what to expect and that’s what I love if I’m going to spend money on drinks. Now as far as the food we only ordered an appetizer since I had already eaten. We order the meatball sliders. The meatballs great the bread just way too much. I believe if they sold the meatballs balls alone would be a mu

My husband and I celebrated our anniversary here last night. We had the pasta, conch fritters, Cobb salad, and Mac and cheese. All the food was great and service was prompt. Love the patio and bar area. Cocktails were also good as was the wine selection. We will be visiting again and hope they consider adding a weekend brunch.

We had high expectations for Old Cutler Inn. The place is charming, small but cozy inside. Unfortunately, the experience didn’t match our expectations. The food was just average, not bad but nothing memorable. The real issue was the extremely slow service. It took over 40 minutes to receive a simple bowl during a Sunday lunch at noon, and the restaurant wasn’t even full. I shared my disappointment with the waiter and the manager applied a discount, which was appreciated, but never came to the table to apologize or acknowledge the delay. They definitely need to improve their systems and service. Overall, there wasn’t anything compelling enough, food or service, to make us want to return. The discount was a nice gesture, but we weren’t there for a bargain; we were hoping for a pleasant Sunda

Our food was great ! Atmosphere was amazing but our service was subpar, our male server with glasses was not attentive nor helpful and gave us misinformation about the Brunch menu. I wish I could give a 5 star review but this service was not worth the $45 per person for breakfast. I will try again but not worth it at all.