Oak Street Pie Company

This Pie Store always produces excellent pies and today I got an apple and a Strawberry-Rhubarb. Love this place!

I've been very eager to try Oak Street Pie Company since moving here. Tonight I tried the French Silk Pie, which is one of my favorite flavors of pie, and it was like eating sand. I tried the crust and filling separately thinking it was the crumbly crust giving it the texture. However, the filling was also gritty. Upon further inspection I could literally see the sugar crystals in the filling and crust. Hopefully the photos provided can properly show what I'm talking about. Maybe the French silk here is not as mousse-like as others, but I personally couldn't finish it. That said, I still do have a peach cobbler that I'm eager to try. The staff were wonderful and helpful. No hate to them or the place in general. I just think the French silk pie could be done better.

Pie. Pie. Me oh my! I loooove buttermilk pie. My husband got the chocolate silk pie. Both pies had a great flavor but I think getting it right before they closed was why it was a little dry. I would love to come back and try it fresh. Fudge and cobbler delish! And the shirts are adorable!

We absolutely love Oak Street Pies! Honestly, they are the best pies I have ever had. I have also had the opportunity to work with the owner through marketing, and the experience I had was great! If you are looking to support a wonderful local business with big heart and delicious treats, Oak Street Pies is where it's at!

We love to pair a stop at Hard 8 down the street with a walk down to this pie shop. This pie shop offers pies that your grandma makes. Is it fancy? No. But it's just good old fashioned pies. I love it because of this very reason. Not trying anything fancy or crazy, just serving up home baked tasting pies. I've had the black berry cobbler and the coconut cream pie and couldn't find any fault with it. Always worth a treat!