NYC Pizza Company

I really wanted to enjoy this pizza, and I wish I was giving them a 5-star review right now. However, this is not New York pizza, and this review is for those who grew up on the real deal. As a New Yorker, I always order a large plain and large white pie. To me, these are two pies you can’t get wrong if you market as a NYC pizza spot. After about a 20 minute wait, the pies came out lukewarm and were just ok at best. The pizza was overall lacking in flavor, crisp, and authenticity. Yes, it was thin, but very floppy. Very cheesy, but somehow lacked in flavor. No fresh ricotta or garlic on the white pie. I can say, after trying a lot of pizza spots in the metro Atlanta/North GA area, this isn’t the worst, by any means. But, it’s not great. I wouldn’t go out of my way to eat here again. With

Some of the best pizza I’ve had! I have lived in Monroe long enough to see three different pizza restaurants in this location and this is by far the most impressive. The pizza is perfect. It doesn’t flop and has a nice thin, crisp bottom crust. The cheese bread may look simple but has an amazing buttery, garlicky flavor. Also, the ranch is some of the best I’ve had! We are so happy to have another pizza restaurant downtown and will be continuing to support this business!

We ordered a 12 Inch Meat Lovers with white sauce and, cheese bread and their brownies. Customer service was good when they were out of sausage and Diet Coke they called and let me know, giving substitute options.

We’ve been trying to get to NYC Pizza Company for months. Today was finally the day and what a day it was. From the warm welcome walking in the door to Colton our server’s personable greeting and comfy booth we were set. Colton’s conversation as he took our order was sincere and pleasant. We ordered a large Supreme pizza. It was absolutely delicious. Just the right amount of toppings and cheese. The crust was amazing and cooked to perfection. There’s too many things that made our dinner far beyond anything we could have imagined. The price was right the pizza was right the people were right and NYC Pizza Company was right. Thanks Colton for making our first visit so perfect. It won’t be the last for sure.

Pizza was top notch, Italian sub was great too! Service was really good and they seemed to be on top of it. Glad Monroe finally has a really good pizza place. Highly recommend!!