NY Pie (Hendersonville)

The pizza here is really good if you like thin crust NY style pizza. Nice and crispy and the toppings were beyond generous. Sauce has good flavor. The only complaint I have was that the $5+ cookie I purchased was stale and tasted a bit rancid. I would not purchase the cookie again unless it was made same day. Constructive criticism: I think they should definitely consider making a small batch of cookies fresh daily instead of making them in advance because this three day old cookie was not good at all for the price. Very dry and stale. I should have double checked the date on them before purchasing. Overall the pizza was very good though so check it out, but maybe skip the cookie.

As someone who grew up in Central New Jersey/NY Metropolitan area, I consider myself to be connoisseur of NY-style pizza. I've lived in southern Kentucky for over 30 years, and it's a great place to live or work, but the pizza is mostly horrendous. That was before I discovered NY Pie in Gallatin. The moment I entered, the aroma told me "you're home!", and gave me a hint as to what expect from their pizza. And it lived up to its promise. I ordered a plain cheese pizza, because great pizza does not require an overwhelming cast of extras that may hide the basic, underlying product. Well, I was not disappointed! The crust was crisp and delicious, the texture of the cheese was great, and the sauce was perfect. New York Pie well worth the hour and 10 minute drive, and I highly recommend it!

My family and I come here at least twice a month, for 3 years. For me, it's the best pizzeria in Hendersonville; they're always friendly and smiling. The manager is very kind and always makes sure to say hello. The place is a little run down in terms of furnishings, but it's still worth it. We'll keep coming back for those delicious, crispy pizzas! Recommended!

The pizza is amazing.... Staff is very pleasant and helpful. Prices are good. Large portions...

I Love NY pie and I absolutely want to give a shout out to my man Joey!! He is awesome he is hard-working he is sweet he is kind and he'll do everything in his power to satisfy customers as much as he possibly can!! And I love her that he's a man of God obviously he's not perfect but other than that he is awesome and I love Joey to death and the atmosphere is fantastic the service is amazing and the food is absolutely perfect!! I would definitely highly recommend this place for pizza and also their garlic knots their cookies just everything about this place is fantastic!! And shout out to the rest of the workers that are there that bust their butts everyday to give literally the best pizza I feel like that's in Hendersonville and it's actually the biggest as well though haha Other than t