Nikki's Custard®

My boyfriend and I stopped in today after lunch for the first time. We were a bit disappointed with the choices of flavors for custard (choc, vanilla or coffee) but we ended up ordering anyways. He got the pumpkin spice latte, and it was very tasty! I had a Starbucks PSL for breakfast otherwise I would have ordered this as well. I opted for a small vanilla custard with peach sauce and graham cracker dust. We also ordered a pint of strawberry oreo custard to go. I just had a tablespoon of it and its absolutely delicious! My only suggestion is to offer 1-2 more flavors of custard in house.

SO GOOD! We stopped in for our first time today, had the daily special and it was so good that we got some pints to take home! The shop itself is so cute and the staff are really sweet, we can’t wait to come back! Editing to add- I really appreciate the allergen notes on their menu. We have gluten free pals who visit often and can’t wait to bring them to Nikki’s!

The place is super cute!! The custard tastes premium with a rich, thick consistency. Great, flavor with lots of options for sauces and or toppings. Customer service was friendly and prompt. A little over priced for what you get. A single scoop (which is not a large portion at all) is $3.89 and almost $.90 each sauce and topping the $$$$ can go up very quick!!! Patio is very dog friendly!

The pistachio custard was scrumptious!! The service was also first rate! I want to shout out Dana and Bethany for excellent service! I wanted to tip, but wasn’t allowed to as I was told by Dana they are paid well. We will definitely go back when in Lancaster.

It's mid. I think it's overpriced for what you get; you've probably tasted something like it before, and there's only outdoor seating. It's not bad, but not good per se. The staff was friendly, but other than that, I don't think it's anything special.